Andrew Clements is a prolific writer. It seems like he puts out a new book every year and they are always winning state awards. I read
Frindle years ago, loved it and recommend it and all his others to many classroom teachers as great read-alouds but I had not kept up with any of his books myself. His books are constantly checked out by students as well so I never felt like I had to work hard at recommending them. Realistic fiction is not my first choice to read and school stories are like what I live everyday so I hadn't bothered.
Last week when I was browsing quietly at the public library I stopped to look at books on CD and the one that called my name was
No Talking! by Mr Clements himself. I put all three CD's into the Volvo's player before I backed out and by the time I was home I was enjoying myself. Keith Nobbs does a good job of portraying both male and female's, young and old. It's an interesting story. A fifth grade boy, Dave Packer is reading information about Ghandi for a report. Dave is intrigued by Ghandi's use of silent meditation and Dave decides to give it a try for just one day. In that first day he listens to another classmate, Lynsey, babble on and on and he yells at her (un-Ghandi-like but he is in fifth grade after all). Competitive by nature, both agree to a challenge, thinking the other will automatically lose! What follows is a look into w
hat happens when students step out of their norm and how much learning can occur at school beyond the general subjects. The students surprise themselves!!
Highly recommended for 3rd-5th grade. I loved the references to Ghandi and thought it could lead to good discussion about him and what he stood for!!This was very enjoyable to listen and I plan on catching up on all my A. Clements school stories by listening in my car.
Click here for Andrew Clement's website.
4 comments:
I didn't particularly love Frindle (I liked it but didn't LOVE it), but I thought "No Talking" was terrific! Very clever and interesting.
Hmm. I will have to go back and reread Frindle. I remember thinking the kid was fairly innovative. I did like "No Talking" and have started "Room One" this morning.
What a clever and realistic way to introduce young readers to Ghandi and some of what he stood for! I'll have to look for this author when my son gets a little older.
Jenners-
That seems to be a little bit of Clements MO-Ghandi, male/female competitiveness in "No Talking" and the one I am listening to now takes an interesting look at homelessness, depression and losing small town America-all in an easy to read chapter book!!
Thanks for your comment!
Post a Comment